Why Common Law Never Made It Past the First Season
In 2012, USA Network introduced Common Law, a buddy cop dramedy that had the potential to be a long-running hit. With its unique premise of two bickering detectives forced into couples therapy, the show brought a fresh and comedic twist to the genre. However, despite its entertaining dynamic and promising cast, Common Law only lasted one season before being canceled. So, what went wrong?
A Unique Take on the Buddy Cop Genre
Common Law followed LAPD detectives Travis Marks (Michael Ealy) and Wes Mitchell (Warren Kole), who were once the department’s best team—until their constant arguing began interfering with their work. In an attempt to fix their partnership, their captain (Jack McGee) ordered them to attend couples therapy, leading to humorous and heartfelt moments as they worked through their issues.
Travis was the free-spirited, street-smart cop with a troubled past, while Wes was the uptight, by-the-books former lawyer who preferred order and structure. Their clashing personalities made for great comedic banter, but underneath the humor was a genuine exploration of partnership and trust.
A Strong but Short-Lived Cast
Michael Ealy as Travis Marks, the laid-back detective with commitment issues.
Warren Kole as Wes Mitchell, the meticulous and somewhat neurotic partner.
Sonya Walger as Dr. Emma Ryan, the couples therapist trying to keep them together.
Jack McGee as Captain Mike Sutton, their boss who forces them into therapy.
Why Common Law Was Canceled
Despite its fun premise and strong performances, Common Law struggled with several issues that contributed to its downfall:
A Difficult Time Slot – The show aired on Friday nights, a historically tough time for new series to build an audience.
Delays in Production – The series had production delays that likely hurt its momentum.
Mixed Ratings – While not terrible, Common Law didn’t pull in strong enough numbers to justify a second season.
Network Priorities – USA Network was shifting its focus, with shows like Suits and White Collar taking priority.
Why Common Law Deserved More Time
The chemistry between Ealy and Kole was one of the show’s biggest strengths, and the therapy sessions added a fresh layer to the buddy cop formula. With more time to develop its storylines and characters, Common Law could have found a loyal fanbase.
Though it ended after just 12 episodes, Common Law remains a fun, underrated watch for fans of witty, character-driven cop dramas. If you missed it during its original run, it’s worth checking out to see what could have been a great long-term series.
